Every listing has two pieces of information hiding in plain sight: how long the home has sat on the market, and whatever story you've been told about why the seller is leaving. Neither one is decoration. Both are checkable, and together they're one of the best negotiation-leverage signals you get before you've even made an offer.

Days on market is public data — use it

Days on market (DOM) is the number of days a home has been actively listed for sale, and it's not a secret the listing agent controls. It's tracked by the MLS and surfaced on every major site — Zillow, Redfin, Realtor.com — usually right next to the price. If a listing has been live for 87 days, you don't have to ask anyone; you can see it.

The mistake buyers make is comparing that number to a fixed idea of "normal," usually some number they half-remember from a headline. That number is close to meaningless without context, because DOM swings wildly by market and season. As of July 2026, the National Association of Realtors reported a national median of 29 days on market, while Redfin's data put the national median closer to 49 days as of June 2026 — the gap is mostly methodology (what counts as "under contract" and when the clock starts/stops), which is itself a good reminder that even "the national number" isn't one clean stat.

Either way, national medians are a weak yardstick. A listing that's been up for 45 days is stale in a hot Midwest suburb where things go under contract in under two weeks, and completely unremarkable in a slower Sun Belt market where 60-90+ days is routine. What matters is the local comparison.

How to find the local number that actually matters

  • Ask your agent for the current average or median DOM in the specific zip code or neighborhood, pulled from the MLS, not a national app default.
  • Look at DOM on 5-10 comparable active and recently-sold listings nearby — same rough price range, similar home type — and eyeball where your target listing falls relative to them.
  • Check whether the market is seasonally slow (winter listings linger everywhere) or unusually fast (spring/summer in most regions).

If a home's DOM is meaningfully above the local average for comparable properties right now, that's a real signal — not proof of anything wrong with the house, but a sign the market has had a chance to bid on it and hasn't moved. That's leverage. It means you can reasonably ask for concessions — price, credits, repairs — that you couldn't ask for on a listing that went live four days ago with three other offers already in.

"Why is the owner selling?" — and why the answer is worth pressure-testing

The listing sheet or agent will usually offer some version of an answer, sometimes unprompted, sometimes only if you ask. Here's the thing to keep in mind: the seller's agent represents the seller, not you, and has no legal obligation to volunteer a reason that makes the house look worse. You're allowed to ask directly, and you're allowed to be skeptical of a vague or shifting answer.

Reasons that are genuinely neutral and usually check out:

  • Job relocation
  • Downsizing (kids moved out, retirement, empty-nesting)
  • Estate sale (inherited property, previous owner passed away)
  • Upsizing for a growing family
  • Divorce (personal, but not a signal about the house itself)

None of those tell you anything is wrong with the property. They're about the seller's life, not the house's condition or the deal's history.

The one worth digging into further: a prior deal on the same property that fell through. If a listing shows a gap in history — listed, went pending, came back on the market — that's worth a specific follow-up question: why did it fall through, specifically? Not "did a deal fall through," but the actual reason, because the reasons matter differently:

  • Financing — the previous buyer's loan fell apart. Could be about that buyer's situation, not the house.
  • Inspection — the previous buyer found something during inspection and walked, renegotiated, or the seller wouldn't budge on repairs. This one's worth pressing on — ask if a copy of that inspection report exists and can be shared.
  • Appraisal — the home appraised below the contract price and the deal couldn't bridge the gap. This tells you something about how the home is priced relative to comparable sales, which is directly useful to you as a negotiating data point.

You can check a home's listing history yourself before you even ask: Zillow and Redfin both show price and listing history, and repeated listing/delisting cycles, a new MLS number on an otherwise-identical listing, or listing photos that don't match the current season are all signs of a relist rather than a truly fresh listing.

Reading the signals together

Individually, a longer-than-average DOM or a soft answer about "why we're selling" might mean nothing. Together, especially alongside a price reduction (also visible in listing history) or a relisted-after-falling-through property, they start forming a pattern worth acting on:

  • Long local-relative DOM + price cuts = the market has spoken; there's room to negotiate on price.
  • Relisted after inspection-related fallout = ask for the prior report, budget for likely findings, and consider your own inspection contingency non-negotiable.
  • Relisted after appraisal fallout = come in prepared to discuss comps directly, since you may hit the same wall.
  • Vague or inconsistent seller-motivation answers, alone, without other red flags = not a dealbreaker, but a reason to ask again, more specifically, before you write an offer.

None of this replaces an inspection or a comps-based offer strategy. But knowing how long a house has really been sitting relative to its own market, and asking a direct, specific "why" instead of accepting a one-line answer, costs you nothing and can save you real money.

Sources